By far the story that got the most comments this week was Kate Taylor’s piece regarding whether Strange Empire could ever become as successful as its Monday night counterpart, Murdoch Mysteries. Here’s a sampling of what people said.
The first issue any supporter of the CBC and Canadian TV in general should have with this is that such comparisons always make one show look good at the other showâ€™s expense: if we want both showâ€™s to do well on CBC, what is constructive about this â€œcomparisonâ€ approach?
Ever wonder why Murdoch Mysteries has a fairly substantial audience? By bringing together a bunch of genres, Murdoch Mysteries came up with something â€œquirkyâ€ and â€œhybridâ€ and â€œcultish.â€ People use a whole lot of compound terms to describe it. But the point is, there is something in Murdoch Mysteries that â€œcrosses overâ€ for many audience segments, so itâ€™s a ridiculous exercise to try to reduce it to some over-simplified strawman just for the same of comparing Strange Empire. All of these articles just makes it look like the reviewers donâ€™t know what they are talking about to the over 1 million viewers who actually do watch Murdoch Mysteries every week.–Snacky
After watching the first two episodes of Strange Empire and having the people I had talked into watching it drop like flies, I began watching the show with a much more critical eye, but an eye which viewed the show in terms of why the show failed to appeal to people, rather than an eye to artistry. After watching five episodes of Strange Empire, I still am not sure exactly where the characters are all going and at this point I`m not sure what I`m hoping for the characters.–Ally
And, as The Bachelor Canada heads into its season finale on Tuesday, readers are split 50-50 over whether Tim Warmels will choose Trish or April as his betrothed.
Unfortunately, I see April as a mentally and emotionally unstable individual. What does Tim know of her background? How will she cope when she begins to have her own children, when she is so easily overwhelmed? It will take a lot of trust and possibly a lot of time in the future to help her deal with lifeâ€™s issues, it seems, not just for Tim but his family.–Evette
I wanted April, but what I saw last week, I have changed my mind. April still needs to mature and really think what she really wants.Â She is very pretty and nice, but what would happen in the real life with Tim? This relationship will not survive. With Trish, this might work, but Tim must set the rules with a beauty queen. No diva, no drama, just be yourself. Moving to Toronto will be a big step with Trish. But I still like Trish.–Luce
Got a comment or question about Canadian TV? Contact me at firstname.lastname@example.org.