Murdoch Mysteries: Yannick Bisson breaks down “Sins of the Father”

Spoiler alert! Do not read on until you have watched the latest episode of Murdoch Mysteries, “Sins of the Father.”

Covering an entire season of Murdoch Mysteries with previews and post-episode interviews—as I have for the past several years—just isn’t complete unless I’ve spoken to Yannick Bisson.

Our chat couldn’t have come at a better time. Monday’s newest, “Sins of the Father,” dealt with the death of Det. William Murdoch’s father, Harry. Though he was only portrayed by Stephen McHattie for two episodes, the impact Harry Murdoch has had on his son has endured. And, unsurprisingly, William acted as though Harry’s demise didn’t affect him. But, as evidence began to suggest murder rather than an accident, William sought justice.

We spoke to Bisson about the episode, his acting choices, Season 12 overall, and his very un-Murdoch-like role in Another Wolfcop where he plays a villain named, yes, Swallows.

I feel like this has become a yearly event, checking in with you. Every year I say, ‘Congratulations on another season,’ but congratulations on Season 12 of Murdoch Mysteries. I’ve loved it so far.
Yannick Bisson: Well, this is my phone call I look forward to because if I’m talking to you, that means we are still in business.

Before we specifically get into ‘Sins of the Father,’ I want to get your take on this season because there have been a few things that have been notable. I want to start with the ‘Sir. Sir? Sir!’ episode, which I think was the most controversial of this season. What was your take on the wacky, Halloween themed episode?
YB: It was great. I mean, we have to take a step aside sometimes and have some fun, and that’s really what a lot of these types of episodes … we’re somewhat blatant with it, so that there’s no mistaking that we’re just going outside the envelope a little bit here and trying something different. We did that in the past with the ‘Weekend at Murdoch’s’ type of episode, so it’s clear that this is not sort of part of the canon if you will, or whatever you want to call that. We’re doing something creative, we’re trying something different, and hopefully, you’re along for the ride. Now, not everybody responded the same way, unfortunately, but we don’t always do it just for the audience. Sometimes we do episodes for us.

As an actor, although you’re enjoying the ride, it is nice to shake things up a bit.
YB: Well, absolutely. I mean, that’s a big part of it for me is doing different things, doing new things, but also within the show having new experiences, meeting new actors and it’s just like any job. It’s great to have new challenges and new opportunities. So, as much as I look forward to other projects completely outside of Murdoch, I also look forward to doing things a little bit differently within Murdoch. That’s been fun to do when we’ve travelled to other countries or done wacky episodes.

William and Julia’s Frank Lloyd Wright house is amazing and not only a refresh for the couple and the set but also the forward-thinking of this couple as we’re gradually moving into further along into the history of the show and the history of Toronto.
YB: Oh, absolutely. It’s good to have these contemporaries sort of float through the timeline of Murdoch, so we’re able to talk about people like Frank Lloyd Wright, which a lot of people associate his work with closer to the 30s and the 20s and stuff like that. So, being able to say, ‘Oh, no, no, no, no. Very early in his career, this is possibly the very first year of his public career,’ and so on. We’re able to do that, which is a lot of fun and certainly educational because I definitely would have pinned him as doing the bulk of his work, or certainly the most notable stuff, in the 30s. I had no idea.

I know it’s a good episode of Murdoch when I quickly go to Google and start Googling things to find out more information.
YB: Yeah, no kidding.

So, this past week was kind of a twofer. First of all, Nikola Tesla, always great to have him on the show and got me reminiscing about ‘Power.’ But also Elvis Stojko, who told me that he had a fantastic time. What was it like working with him one-on-one in the interrogation room?
YB: Oh, he was hilarious. I mean, I was laughing out loud at stuff that he was doing and it certainly wasn’t expected. I didn’t know at all what to expect, especially since on the page, that particular scene was pretty funny and then for him to come in and actually be even funnier was a really pleasant surprise. I mean, such a great guy. We reconnected since in the skating world. I went and visited their Thank You Canada show with Tessa Virtue and Scott Moir and Elvis. So, it was a cool connection to make and I’m just so hugely proud of our Olympic athletes. As you know, I’m a very, very proud Canadian, so it was just like heaven for me and then for him to do such a knockout job. It was hilarious.

He didn’t want to look as though he was a figure skater showing up and not be taken seriously.
YB: That’s right. That’s right. He told me about that. He’s also got that mindset of if you want to accomplish something, you’re gonna have to put in the work. You gotta prep. You gotta do what you gotta do and then you’re gonna get the results out of it with the effort that you put in. That seems to be his approach, and it’s kind of cool. Everybody has a different process, a different approach. I certainly appreciated that.

Let’s get into Monday’s episode. The director, Mina Shum, filmed some beautiful scenes of William. The quiet one at the beginning of the episode where he’s in the forest, and then in Harry’s room, going through the suitcase and those old memories. Very unlike some of the scenes that we see in Murdoch.
YB: Yeah, it was funny, from the moment the script came up I started to sort of feel a lot of that stuff and feel a lot of that sense of helplessness, that sense of being let down, the sense of incomplete relationship, a sense of anger, all those different things. It was easy. It came off the page very, very easily for me. The weather cooperated in so many ways because of that read of looking up to the sky and seeing possibly something. I actually added that in, I think. I know I did in a couple of spots. I’m not sure if it was my idea altogether, but I know that I added it in a couple of spots and when I saw the edit, I saw that they kept it in there, so that was interesting because I sort of thought it was almost as if Murdoch conceded to the fact that his father went the way that he should go and that he’s up there and he’s sort of conceded to what Julia says about maybe it was this, maybe it was that. In the end, it may not be perfect, but it was the way it was.

So, the weather kind of cooperated with that, which was kind of weird because at first, it’s gloomy, it’s dark. It’s very unclear and then towards the end, the sky’s starting to part a little bit and it’s a little more clarity. It created a cool symbolism of what Murdoch was feeling.

It was quite interesting to see Simon McNabb credited for the episode because when I think of him, I’m not necessarily thinking of those emotional moments, I’m thinking of funnier moments.
YB: Yeah. And that just goes to show you the depth of our lineup, the depth of our roster, you know?

When William is in the morgue and Harry’s body’s on the table, William is as about as far away from the body as you can get without being out of frame. Was that a conscious decision that he just doesn’t want to go near the body?
YB: Yeah, definitely. I played that physically in tone. He, I thought, very early on put a wall between himself and the entire situation and that becomes clear in the dialogue between the other characters of the story, but he definitely throws up a wall and is protecting himself, but also doesn’t want to lower himself to some possibly very base level, even though he would for other people. He would seek out justice for other people, but with his own father for some reason, he was judge, jury and executioner and so I wanted to physically show that.

I’m sad that Harry’s not going to be around anymore. I kept thinking, ‘OK, maybe it wasn’t him.’ 
YB: Yeah, I know. I know. The reality is it’s probably really difficult to get Stephen McHattie, but there’s also a great opportunity in that script, so it’s like you gotta pick and choose.

Speaking of actors, I couldn’t believe that Sara Botsford and Peter McNeil, neither of them had been on Murdoch Mysteries until Monday night. What was it like working with them?
YB: I know, isn’t that funny? Peter and I go way, way back and Sara, obviously she’s been part of Canadian fabric for so long. It was so incredible to have them both there and I thought a real privilege. They were both so sweet. They were both so complimentary and proud of the show and the accomplishments of the show and the cast. It was just such a sweet time to have them there because these guys are veterans. People like Peter have appeared in some of the biggest movies ever. So, it was just very sweet for them to A) take the time to do the episode with us and then B) to just come around and just, ‘Heck yeah, we want to be part of this. We’re so proud of you guys.’ So, it was a very sweet time.

We just got a handful of episodes left before the end of the season. Obviously, you’re not going to give anything away, but I’m assuming it’s going to be a bit of a rollercoaster heading into the two-part season finale?
YB: Yeah, we’ve got a pretty great season this year. It’s funny because it didn’t feel all that different when we started out. It was like, ‘Alright, we’re doing this. Oh, we’re going to try a weird alien episode? OK.’ Do you know what I mean? We’ve done zombies before, so why not? But, I’m getting so many comments from people saying that it’s just a standout year and stellar and can’t believe we’re this far into it and it’s still so creative and there’s still so much still to offer. So, that really makes me happy, because I’m somewhat isolated a little bit. I film the show. There’s nobody around and then when people are watching the show, I’m not around. So, it’s a little bit strange to be sort of disconnected completely. But, the word on the street is that this is a great year

The writing room is turning out stories that continue to be incredible, and then with the fact that we got to see some back stories of some of the supporting characters, this has just been a great season all around.
YB: Absolutely, and funny enough, all of that great sort of enriching of the secondary characters, everybody’s back story, has actually been a huge blessing for me this past year because it gave me so much downtime that I’m starting to wonder if I was getting written out of my own show. But, it was really great and I think the show has been better for it, because a lot of people are attached to … the bandwidth is much broader now, the attachment to the characters and to their story and to what they want.

One last question. How much fun was it being in Another WolfCop? I saw the movie over the holidays on Super Channel, and man, you’re fantastic in it.
YB: Oh, I’m so glad to hear when people have seen that. It was such a blast. I actually enjoyed working with those guys so much that I partnered up in the production company and we’ve since made some other projects and there are more coming. But yeah, the whole WolfCop thing was so much fun and being able to play that just hugely reprehensible character, it was so great, so great.

It’s worth it just to hear you swear.
YB: Oh, I had a whole bunch more. I had a whole bunch more because they would just tell me, ‘OK, start ripping.’ We banked all kinds of stuff that the world will just never view. But I tell you, that was fun. It was kind of like decades of holding back and I just let loose on it.

Murdoch Mysteries airs Mondays at 8 p.m. on CBC and streams at CBC Gem.

Images courtesy of CBC.


22 thoughts on “Murdoch Mysteries: Yannick Bisson breaks down “Sins of the Father””

  1. Why is it I’ve never heard of Willam’s brother Japser until the last Xmas special and why does he have a different last name?

    1. William met Jasper at the end of season two. They are half brothers. Jasper is RCMP. I just rewatched the episode “Anything You Can Do”.

  2. Au contraire. The whacko episodes of MM are definitely part of the “canon”. The canon is so eclectic that there is room for any concept. It’s what makes MM a mystery. You never know what’s coming: serious drama, off the wall comedy, a procedural, sci-fi. Love it!

  3. Living in the USA there is a large number of Murdochians if you read our posts on tweeter you will see how everything and everyone associated with the show is loved 💗🥰 hoping that the cast and crew don’t get sick of doing the show it would be a great loss to all hope we hear 👂 soon that it’s been picked up again if not I and many others will have something to say I have all but season 12’s DVD’S so I can view at anytime I want
    Thank you for giving us onsite into the show and conversations with Yannick

  4. Honestly so lucky to be able so see such good actors perform at an excellent caliber and performing at their best. Your storyline draws you in to the very end and I appreciate Yannicks update with his personal output of his ideas which makes me feel Murdoch Mysteries will be here for a whole. Thanks

  5. Thoroughly enjoying info have not seen this weeks ep yet .so far season 12 has been a credit to the writers and actors it just gets better .if thats possible .everything about mm is simply the best in every way 😍🇦🇺

  6. Great episode!
    Wonderful storyline, a great script deep psychological drama of the main characters.
    The acting game of Yannick Bisson, Helen Joy, Thomas Craig and Johnny Harris at the highest level as always!
    Thank you for the interview with Yannick Bisson, he is very talented. It’s good that Yannick Bisson and Helen Joy are involved in other projects, but not sure that these projects will be as successful and super popular in different countries as Murdoch Mysteries. This is a unique show in which each next season is more interesting than the previous one. We really hope for the 13th and next seasons with the obligatory participation of our four favorite characters!
    Thanks to the whole Murdoch Mysteries team!

    1. All above I agree with you and I think more needs to be said about the research on reconciliation to the writers and behind the scenes team that work tiredly to produce our on going Murdoch Mysteries in hopes this will get a year 13

      BRAVO 👏

  7. I thought this was a superb episode. Congratulations to the writer Simon McNabb, the director, the cast and in particular Yannick Bisson and Helene Joy. It was a good exploration of grief and how people react. William’s reaction when he realised it was his father, spoke volumes. Then he put up a wall, reminiscent of his early relationship with Julia. I found the scene when he confronted the culprits, when he pointed the gun and then ended up on the ground, very moving. It was so not like Detective Murdoch, but it was a son , grieving for his father and his father’s reputation.
    This time, William had Julia to talk him through the experience and help him come to terms with his loss. At this point in the series, it’s wonderful to see these issues handled in such a mature and sensitive way. Thank you.

  8. I agree with the recall of Lily M. This is a great dramatic episode with amazing psychological scenes. The character of William is shown with deep internal contradictions between the feelings of a son and the shock of a possible crime of the father. The last scene in the cemetery, in which William can hardly hold back tears, is generally amazing in terms of psychological impact. But this scene does not leave pessimism, because our detective has a loving intelligent wife who understands him well, has friends and favorite work. He is not alone.
    Murdoch Mysteries – you are the best!

  9. Question. What was the religious persuasion Dan Nelson’s cellmate said he was?? I thought I heard christadelpian. Great episode btw.

    1. Hi David it seems i@others are unsure and the only way to know is to watch the whole show again an it’s not available yet. If I find out I will advise

    1. That’s really interesting because that’s the faith community I’m a member of which has been around since the mid 1800s We’re a small christian lay community not very well known so I was completely gob smacked when it was referenced. I would be interested in knowing how the writers were aware of our existence.

  10. Hello David. I’ve Looked into the writers history on your question but there is no giving away on some details except the show features historically accurate writing with investigative homework for details on sets with stories inspired by true to life events.

    1. Thanks for inquiring . The Christadelpians were relatively numerous in the early part of the 20th century at least by our standards and had a number of congregations in southern ontario including Toronto. My great grandparents, Harry and Gertrude Styles, were leading members in our community in Brantford. I suppose it’s possible that an inmate became a Christadelpian and penned a statement of faith. Any historical info that the writers can share would be appreciated.

  11. It was great to get Yannick’s point of view on the episode. Stellar cast, stellar stort, stellar writing.

  12. I loved the Halloween episode and thought it was funny and actually thought provoking too (maybe aliens would be an improvement.) I am truly amazed how good each episode is and how emotional some of them make me feel year after year. BRAVO!

Comments are closed.