With only a few more episodes to go, Heartland fans were torn over whether Peter and Lou’s marriage really is on the rocks and several readers weighed in on this week’s He Said/She Said column regarding how “Canadian” Canadian TV shows should be.
I donâ€™t want them to separate because of the girls but I think Peter has been kind of selfish throughout their relationship (not that Lou hasnâ€™t made her share of mistakes) Iâ€™d like to see a bit more character growth on the show though. Seems like every character is stuck in their own ways. Especially Tim and Lou.â€”Amber
I personally wouldnâ€™t want Lou and Peter to separate, but I have to agree it would be interesting to see how the writers wold have it happen. I think they will end up being together but itâ€™s sure going to be a rough[er!] ride. I donâ€™t know how they would do it.Â As for the vow renewal, maybe itâ€™s kind of selfish but I wouldnâ€™t like to see them â€œstealâ€ Amy and Tyâ€™s moment hahaha!Â This was an amazing episode. Got me in tears! The show just keeps getting better and better!â€”Luiza
I always liked Peter, and do hope that he and Lou can work things out. (Plus, Iâ€™ve loved Peterâ€™s interactions with Georgie, and Katie seems to miss him when heâ€™s not around.)Â Itâ€™s not as if Heartland hasnâ€™t had the theme of divorce lurking in the background; Tim and Marion divorced. Lisa is a divorcÃ©e (Dan Hartfield was her first husband). Most notably, Caleb Odell and Ashley Stanton split not long after they got married.Â This would be the first time one of â€œthe familyâ€ came undone front and centre (and not as a matter of ancient family history).
But I like what youâ€™ve posited: If Lou and Peter can get their act together, it sure would be nice to see them renew their vows when Amy and Ty make their vows (though I think there would be some in the Amy/Ty camp who would want it to be *their* day, and their day alone).â€”TheRealTC
Wow, Diane. You said things perfectly. To me, setting is important. I look at my favourite 20 current shows (Downton Abbey, Orphan Black, Call the Midwife, Outlander, Nashville, Parenthood, Vikings, The Originals, The 100, Empire, Revenge, Finding Carter, Chasing Life, Greyâ€™s Anatomy, Hard Rock Medical, Hart of Dixie, Orange is the New Black, Longmire, Arrow and Mohawk Girls) and only twoâ€“Orphan Black and Finding Carterâ€“donâ€™t have defined settings. However, neither seem to go out of their way to hide their setting; they just donâ€™t clarify it.
What I have a problem with when it comes to several Canadian shows is that they seem to go out of their way to hide their Canadianness or they take on an American identity. That aggravates me more than anything else. Americans have enough stories if their own being told on television and we shouldnâ€™t be telling more for them. We have our own stories to tell and our setting isnâ€™t a negative. I go to a lot of U.S. TV sites and I never hear a complaint from Americans if thereâ€™s something Canadian in a show. The same goes for British dramas and the British accents: Downton Abbey, Sherlock, Broadchurch and The Fall all get great ratings in the States yet U.S. networks keep trying to remake them as Americanized stories.â€”Alicia
Got a question or comment about Canadian TV? firstname.lastname@example.org or head to @tv_eh.