Murdoch Mysteries: Showrunner Peter Mitchell looks ahead to Season 11

Spoiler alert! Do not read on until you’ve watched Murdoch Mysteries Episode 18, “Hell to Pay.”

Now that was one heck of a season finale, wasn’t it Murdoch Mysteries fans? It’s a good thing our favourite series has been greenlit for another season because there are a ton of questions to be answered! Will Julia be found? How will William get out of this scrape? Is Det. Watts really there to help William? Did Brackenreid fight off Davis, or is he injured or, gulp, dead? And, perhaps most importantly: did Higgins, Crabtree and Jackson all survive the gunfire?

We spoke to Murdoch Mysteries showrunner Peter Mitchell about that edge-of-your-seat instalment—the show’s landmark 150th—and where the show goes in Season 11.

First of all, congratulations on your writing win at the Canadian Screen Awards, as well as Murdoch Mysteries winning the Golden Screen Award. Is it important to you to win awards, specifically one for writing?
Peter Mitchell: Murdoch has never gotten a nomination for writing, so it was important to give a little shout-out to the writers. It’s nice to win an award, but it’s not why I’m here. I think I’ve been nominated 11 times or something and this is the first time I’ve won. Winning is better than losing. [Laughs.] I won’t deny that. It was nice of the movie to win too as a whole. Obviously, I’m biased but getting the award for most viewership is more important than anything else.

Let’s talk about the cliffhanger season finale, ‘Hell to Pay.’ I seem to remember Murdoch being framed for murder once before?
I believe he was at the end of Season 4 [“Murdoch in Wonderland”]. That was just before my time. I don’t think it was a cliffhanger, he was exonerated by the end of the episode.

At what point did you decide ‘Hell to Pay’ would be a cliffhanger?
I think it was around the time that we thought Trump was going to win [the election]. I just figured everything would go to hell both fictionally and in real life.

It was great to see Robin Dunne back on TV. I haven’t seen him since Sanctuary.
He was great. I had never met him before, actually, and he was a ton of fun. It was also especially fun to work with John Wildman, who was on a TV show called The Campbells a million years ago and I used to drive him to work. That’s the first time we had worked together in, like, 30 years.

You started out in the industry as a driver?
Well, as a production assistant. They didn’t have drivers back then. I was the general gofer guy.

How long were you a P.A.?
One season, and then I moved into the writing department fairly quickly once I got my foot in the door.

Did you take a TV writing course at the time?
I took one television writing course at York University for, like, a semester. My instructor was in the business, at CTV, and he got me a gig.

OK, let’s talk about the episode. Miss Cherry’s personality has certainly evolved. In last week’s episode, she was talking shit about William and Julia. There is no faster way to turn the fans on someone than having them do that.
Yeah, especially Julia. We learned that when one of the characters Emily was involved with called William a stick in the mud. That was basically her death sentence. [Laughs.] But we had portrayed Louise as being controlling over George throughout, but it was when she insults George’s friends that he can do better. I kind of knew what the reaction would be.

Is that it for Louise Cherry?
I wouldn’t say so, no. She performs a function in the finale and is not out of the picture.

With regard to Inspector Brackenreid … we hear a gunshot and last saw Davis aiming a gun at his head. 
We hear a gunshot go off and that’s the last we see of Brackenreid. I guess we’ll see what happens.

It appears we might be losing one of the constables. Murdoch is told that one of them is dead.
I think you have to think about the reliability of the narrator, the person who is telling him that. I don’t think we can end a season like that and have everything be tickety-boo. The show, in essence, has five cliffhangers: three constables, one Julia and a Brackenreid. And we don’t see any of them past the three-quarter mark of the show. And, why is Watts offering to be so helpful at the very end of the episode? Is he a good guy? I don’t know. Why didn’t he help Murdoch earlier? Why is he showing up now?

So, Watts may have ulterior motives?
Maybe. I never trust those Maslanys. They have many faces! [Laughs.] Daniel is fantastic; just a very pleasant young man.

You’ve created this mess with all of these characters. How do you clean it up going forward?
I think it’s a big enough mess that it will take more than one episode to clean it up. I’ve been studiously avoiding the hard work of making it all make sense. I think what I’ll probably do is use a couple of the early episodes to deal with the repercussions of last year and then bounce the show ahead three months in time because I don’t think we’re purpose built to go dark, dark, dark. We’re allowed to go dark on the show but I don’t think we can stay there.

Are there any historical characters you’re planning on bringing on board for Season 11?
I think we’re going to bring back good old Teddy Roosevelt. I think we’re going to bring Dr. William Osler back, one of the founders of modern medicine. I think we’re going to bring in Helen Keller, who will help solve a case. And, with Helen Keller, I think we’re going to get Alexander Graham Bell. That’s just in the early stages right now and I think we’re going to try and pay a tiny bit more attention to getting more historical characters in this year than we did last year. That might entail the return of Laurier and Terrence Meyers, of course, some of the regular characters we like to see every year.

In terms of the historical characters, they all seem to be in the world of medicine for some reason.

What did you think of the season finale? Let me know in the comments below!

Images courtesy of CBC.

Greg David
Follow me

Greg David

Prior to becoming a television critic and owner of TV, Eh?, Greg David was a critic for TV Guide Canada, the country's most trusted source for TV news. He has interviewed television actors, actresses and behind-the-scenes folks from hundreds of television series from Canada, the U.S. and internationally. He is a podcaster, public speaker, weekly radio guest and educator, and past member of the Television Critics Association.
Greg David
Follow me

13 thoughts on “Murdoch Mysteries: Showrunner Peter Mitchell looks ahead to Season 11”

  1. Sounds like a doozy! Can’t wait to see it. On the historical figures: Bring back L.M. Montgomery!! Go to PEI this time and have her help with a case. She loved ghost stories and wrote quite a few. In 1905, she finished writing AoGG and started trying to get it published. George could help her with that. She won’t meet Ewen (her future husband) for another year. And 2018 will be the 110th anniversary of the publication of AoGG. I like the idea of bringing Helen Keller in. If we have Teddy again, could we please have a young Eleanor Roosevelt, too? They were close cousins. She got married to Franklin in 1905, so we could see him, too.

  2. I watched the final episode and was completely taken in with it. When will the next episode be aired? I just can’t wait but in the meantime I watch reruns of other episodes

  3. My significant other and myself sat and watched spellbound throughout this episode. It moved so fast from one catastrophic event to another. When the show ended I sat with my mouth open, not wanting to believe that the show was over leaving everyone in the precarious positions. Can’t wait for the new season to begin.

  4. I love this series especially that it s not dark and twisted but enlightening with historical figures and inventions. I hope it keeps on in that vein. Great writing.

  5. how dare you leave us hanging like this! We are seniors and can’t take this suspense…..
    Hope we live to see the new season. Now where’s my heart pills?

  6. I’m a grandmother and watch every recorded episode with my 2 granddaughters. We prop up on pillows in my bed and have lots of snacks (some healthy and some not so much) and enjoy our favourite friend, William Murdoch. Of course we love Julia and our funny friend George Crabtree. I saw the last episode which was a nail biter. I will make sure that the girls will see it long before lights out…no need for nightmares!!
    Yannick Bisson is my favourite actor ever! I wasn’t a good history student and I love learning about our early history through Murdoch Mysteries. I am thrilled to know that season 11 is in the making! Thank you! Thank you!

  7. I LOVE this show so much! It’s so much better than the movies that they show in the cinema nowadays. Now I just can’t wait for the next season to air! But I have to say this last episode was almost too dark, everything escalated so quickly and I was so upset by the idea that some of my favourite heroes might be dead! In any case, I’m really looking forward to see what will happen in season 11!

  8. I can’t believe what I just saw in the last five minutes. I love the show but I think I’m going into depression.
    I enjoyed the fact that the feathers were ruffled and everything is not dandy. However, I think the writers pushed it just a little to far wit the 5 cliff hangers; 3-4 would have sufficed.
    I hope the next episode will be released soon because I don’t know how long I can go without sleep. I sincerely hope Julia survives as well as Crabtree and Brackenreid. It would be a shame if such an inspirational woman character was to be killed off.
    P.S I want to congratulate the actors who have done an excellent job this season and thank them for their hard work. Especially William and Julia whom are great inspirations in character, thought, intelligence, morals, opinion and as actors themselves.
    Your Biggest Fan Evelina.

  9. Could we return to the former “solve a mystery” style of Murdoch Mysteries? I’m not really a fan of my lead characters being exposed to so much danger. I felt that the last episode was “dark”! I was happier when William , George and Julia were investigating and solving other people’s problems. You have a superb cast of characters here!

  10. Hi, I am Australian also. I watched this episode last night. I am still stunned today. I searched the TV guides to find the next episode but to no avail. I sat stunned at the end, mouth agape. OMG. The stress. Who might die, who might live ?. I don’t want to lose any. How will Brackenreid’s wife cope without him. ?I even went so far as to blame Murdoch. Why didn’t he listen to Brackenreid and leave it alone for now, and now look at the mess. !!! Didn’t he know they would use Julia to draw him out, and that the constables were being followed to the church. We are Murdoch Mysteries fanatics in our house. Please Series 11, hurry up and put us out of our misery asap.
    Thank you, Yvonne from Melbourne.

  11. Me too! Oh goodness, that was cruel! Hubby and I were on the edge of our seats! How long ’til season 11 in Oz? Soon we hope! 😮

  12. Warning (Spoilers)

    I’m pretty sure George, Henry and Brackenreid are alive. My money’s on Jackson being dead.

    I think there’s several reason for this:

    1) George and Brackenreid are far too important to die, and the viewers love them.

    2) Higgins is the comic relief, and he has great chemistry with George, so that makes it less likely he’ll die.

    3) Jackson suddenly became very important this season, which is suspicious. There’s also his friendship with Detective Watts, who shows up right at the end and tells Murdoch he’ll help him.

    My guess is Jackson died, which upset Watts, who’s now willing to help Murdoch.

    But guess we’ll find out when season 11 premieres.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *