UPDATE:Â If the intent is to attract “top talent” that will make all these new “American” Canadian shows more viable, the CRTC should probably know that even some of the most successful Canadians in L.A., like the showrunner/creator of Bones, isn’t impressed.
Canadian Television is about to become slightly less full of Canadians, thanks to a major CRTC decision released quietly yesterday.
The CRTC is allowing the independent production funds (including the Shaw Rocket Fund, Rogers Fund, Cogeco Program Development Fund, Telefilm Canada, and the Harold Greenberg Fund) to reduce their â€œpoint systemâ€ for what determines Canadian-ness of a project from 8 to 6. The general effect of this will be to allow for the hiring of non-Canadians in key creation and starring roles (ie: Americans will be able to create and star in â€œCanadianâ€ TV series).
This, in fact, by the CRTCâ€™s own admission, was one of the points of the decision:
â€œThe current criterion requiring eight out of 10 Canadian content certification points to qualify for CIPF funding is restrictive and excludes many productions that could otherwise be of high quality and qualify as Canadian. Moreover, a reduced requirement could help smaller and perhaps more innovative projects to qualify for funding. A reduced requirement of at least six points could also facilitate the hiring by production companies of non-Canadian actors or creators, who may increase a project’s attractiveness and visibility in international markets.â€
Reaction from the Canadian creative community was swift, and critical.
Whatâ€™s particularly unusual about this decision is that something with far-reaching implications was done as a â€œpaper hearing,â€ ie: the CRTC did not hold any public consultations.
The last time something like this was proposed, the Writers Guild of Canada brought a group of screenwriters to Hull to appear before the commission. They made a convincing case as to why this â€œflexibilityâ€ wouldnâ€™t lead to better quality Canadian programming. It seems that current chairman J.P. Blais was determined to not repeat this exercise.
Of concern to fans of actual Canadian TV shows, of course, is the fact that once again in no way was the audience consulted. The CRTC didnâ€™t bother to seek out or try to understand the feelings of fans who celebrate unique Canadian points-of-view and creative directions on display in Canadian-created shows such as Orphan Black, Flashpoint, X Company, Letterkenny, Wynonna Earp, Lost Girl, Rookie Blue, Saving Hope, Motive, or many more.
As Peter Mitchell, executive producer and showrunner of Murdoch Mysteries explained on Facebook, even the premise of the CRTCâ€™s decision is faulty:
The problem with the CRTCâ€™s decision is that it really doesnâ€™t advance any new idea. Many Canadian producers have been doing their level best to copy â€œAmerican-styleâ€ shows for years, watering down the Canadian creative role as much as possible. They never seem to do as well as the original work such as Orphan Black or Murdoch Mysteries. Thatâ€™s why youâ€™re not seeing Season 4 of the forgettable XIII, and why Houdini & Doyle, which debuted to so much fanfare, died a quiet death.
The idea that Canadian producers will be able to attract top American talent is dubious at best. Because if youâ€™re American, and youâ€™re working in the American industry where thereâ€™s more money, and more prestige, why would you take a massive pay cut to work in Canada? Instead of top American talent, youâ€™re likelier to get the people who canâ€™t get hired anymore, who might have had credits in the 1980s or 1990s. And now the CRTC has blessed the idea that these marginal players are more valuable than the top homegrown talent who are responsible for the industryâ€™s top successes.
There are other ways to approach the idea of creating hits, rather than this failed road. But the CRTC seems to be enamored with the fantasy that â€œflexibilityâ€ fixes all, rather than actually supporting talent.
And the best part? A government that ran at least partially on a platform of promoting culture is signalling to the next generation of storytellers not to botherâ€”that itâ€™s time to leave:
So thereâ€™s nothing good here if youâ€™re a Canadian writer or actor hoping to star in or create a Canadian show. Or if youâ€™re someone who likes the unique point of view you see from Canadian TV shows. But the producerâ€™s association loves it. Iâ€™m sure youâ€™ll be getting something great from that writer who did one episode of Simon & Simon any day now.
Great news, isnâ€™t it?